Your spot to relax
Experience Benny's Pizza
Located at 1102 W Lincoln Ave in Milwaukee, Benny's Pizza offers a delightful array of delicious offerings, from classic pizzas to unique specialties like the Italian beef combo and pizza puffs. Customers rave about the crunchy thin crust, fresh toppings, and flavorful sauces that elevate each bite, making it a local favorite. Whether you're in the mood for a loaded sausage pizza or a grilled chicken sandwich, Benny's does not disappoint. With its friendly staff and a cozy atmosphere perfect for hangouts, Benny's Pizza stands out as a must-visit destination for both pizza lovers and casual diners alike.
Featured Choices
Taste what’s trending on the menu
Chef Salad
Chicken Parmigiana
Hot Dog
Polish Sausage
Inside the Experience
Benny's Pizza
Welcome to Benny's Pizza, a beloved staple nestled in the heart of Milwaukee, WI. Located at 1102 W Lincoln Ave, this charming pizzeria has earned a loyal following for its mouthwatering offerings and welcoming ambiance. As you step inside, the classic feel is apparent, making it a cozy spot for friends and families alike.
Benny's Pizza shines with a diverse menu that caters to various tastes. From their signature pizzas to hearty sandwiches, the dishes consistently receive rave reviews from patrons. For instance, a customer named James V couldn't resist the enticing combination of sausage, green pepper, bacon, and jalapeño on his pizza, a choice that revealed the kitchen's knack for bold flavors.
The standout element at Benny's is undoubtedly their crust. We The People Wolfpack shared an experience where the thin crust of their standard Pepperoni and Sausage pizza was both crunchy and firm, supporting generous toppings that burst with freshness. Vegetables like green peppers, onions, and mushrooms came alive, enhanced further by a masterfully crafted tangy sauce and abundant mozzarella cheese.
If you're looking for a quick bite, Benny's delivers speed without sacrificing quality. As Donovan noted, the “Family” sized pizza comes at an incredibly reasonable price, making it a fantastic value for families or groups. The friendly staff, reminiscent of a more personal dining experience, adds to the charm of this neighborhood gem.
While pizza is the name of the game, don't overlook other fantastic selections like the Italian beef combo or pizza puff, as recommended by loyal customer Noah Campbell. This highlights the versatility of Benny's menu; it’s a place where you can enjoy pizza but also discover other culinary delights that stand out just as much.
Kush Jordan, a long-time patron, fondly recalls his first visit back in 2013. Since then, Benny's has transformed into a culinary haven where friends gather for good food and camaraderie.
In summary, Benny's Pizza is more than just a place to grab a slice; it's a local institution where quality food and a warm environment come together seamlessly. Whether you're seeking a classic pizza or exploring unique menu items, Benny's is sure to hit the spot!
Stories & Reviews
Guestbook
“ Food was really good. I got a sausage green pepper bacon jalapeño pizza and a grilled chicken sandwich. ”
“ Ordered a Pepperoni, Sausage, Green Pepper, Onion, Mushroom pizza, My standard, and wasn't disappointed at all. The thin crust was crunchy, & firm, Pepperoni burst with fresh flavor, likewise with the sausage. The green peppers, onions and mushrooms were fresh, all enhanced by a flavorful sauce with tang, and generous mozzarella cheese with it's own tang. What keeps this from being a five star rating was while ordering it, the Person taking the order seemed annoyed, and after each ingredient asked in an exasperated voice, "Is that it?", then, when I said, "Yes, that's it", He said "fine", then, due to My upstairs location, took My suggestion of calling Me when the delivery Person was there, said, "why not just be down there?" I said, "It's raining, maybe I should just cancel if You expect Me to stand in the rain." At the very least, questionable Customer service. I will order again, because the Pizza was excellent, but if the Customer Service is as gruff, and annoyed, surprised that a Customer surprisingly doesn't want to, on a 43 degree night, STAND IN THE RAIN! ”
“ Got their pizza for the first time in about 10 years, great taste, quality, etc. Man at the counter was nice, Inside had a classic feel to it, and the “Family” sized pizza only took about 15-20 minutes. Pricing was amazing too considering how big the pizza was, the 3 toppings, and the great quality. 10/10 definitely coming back again and again. ”
“ Might be my favorite local restaurant and the only place where I've actually never ordered a pizza. I always buy the special items like the Italian beef combo or the pizza puff. Staff is also friendly and respectful. ”
“ Tried Benny’s for the first time in 2013 and haven’t been disappointed since! Started coming here as a local hangout and grub spot for me and the guys & overtime it just turned into a true delicacy. I recommend anyone to come in for a nice cozy GrubHub spot. The food definitely hit the spots with a variety of choices from burgers to pizza puffs. ”